In today’s business environment, controlling overhead is more important than ever. For many UK small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and charities, one hidden drain on their finances comes from the way they source energy: via third-party intermediaries or brokers. The “business energy broker dilemma” reflects a growing concern: are energy brokers working in the best interest of your business, or are you paying hidden commissions without realising?
In this long-read blog, we explore how energy brokers can quietly hide fees, why regulation is finally catching up, and concrete steps your business can take to avoid overpaying. We draw on recent developments from the UK government and Ofgem, offer practical advice, and help you make smarter choices when sourcing business energy.
What Is the “Business Energy Broker Dilemma”?
The Appeal of Energy Brokers
Many businesses, especially small ones, don’t have the time or expertise to compare dozens of energy suppliers, tariffs, and contract terms. Using a broker or third-party intermediary (TPI) can therefore seem like a sensible shortcut. As the official regulator states, you can set up a business energy contract yourself or work with a broker.
At first glance, this seems convenient; the broker supposedly negotiates a good deal for you, and you avoid the hassle of dealing with energy suppliers directly. This convenience is what makes brokers appealing.
The Hidden Cost: Commission Embedded In Supply Rates
But therein lies the dilemma. Many energy brokers claim their service is “free”, but in reality, their commission is often embedded in the rates or fees your business pays to the energy supplier.
Because the commission is hidden, businesses rarely know how much of their energy bill is actually going to the broker rather than to the supplier , and this makes it almost impossible to compare quotes fairly.
Some brokers have even been accused of misleading businesses, securing long-term and disadvantageous contracts while keeping their real income secret.
Studies and cases suggest that the impact is not trivial: businesses may end up paying significantly more than they would under a transparent, commission-free contract.
Compare Business Energy Plans
The Regulatory Response: Government and Ofgem Step In
Ofgem’s Role and the Push for Reform
Historically, energy brokers and TPIs have operated largely unregulated, especially when it comes to business energy contracts. That lack of oversight enabled some to hide commission fees without disclosing them to customers.
Recognising this problem, in late 2025 the UK government confirmed that it will bring energy brokers under formal regulation by Ofgem. This includes third-party intermediaries.
Specifically, after legislation, brokers will need to register with Ofgem, comply with “fit and proper” standards, and abide by conduct rules designed to protect businesses from unethical practices.
What Changes for Businesses
- From 1 October 2024, suppliers are required to disclose any fees paid to TPIs, as part of the contract terms. For microbusinesses, the fee must be shown as a total cost for the contract’s duration; for larger non-domestic customers, it must be displayed as a “cost per unit.”
- Brokers will no longer be able to claim “free service” while embedding their payment invisibly into your rates. Transparency will be mandated by regulation.
- Businesses will have clearer visibility on how much commission is being paid, making it easier to compare real costs and choose a supplier or broker wisely.
These regulatory changes mark a major shift , the “wild west” of unregulated brokers may finally be coming to an end. Many see this as an overdue step to restore trust and fairness in the business energy market.
Real-World Impact: Hidden Commissions and Claims
The consequences of opaque commissions have sometimes been severe. In one high-profile case, a court awarded compensation after concluding that brokers had “deliberately concealed” additional fees added to a business’s energy bills.
Legal firms claim that many businesses have mis-sold energy contracts, paying far more than necessary, and are now seeking to reclaim those hidden payments.
Estimates suggest that businesses may be able to recover between 10% and 20% of their prior energy bills , or even more, depending on the contracts and the period of overpayment.
This isn’t just about savings , it’s about fairness and transparency. Many businesses unwittingly paid inflated rates simply because they didn’t know a broker was being paid.
How to Protect Your Business: Practical Steps
The good news is: whether you’ve fallen victim to hidden commissions before or you’re just signing up for a new energy contract, there are clear, actionable steps you can take to avoid the “business energy broker dilemma.”
1. Ask for Full Disclosure , In Writing
When dealing with any broker or TPI, insist they provide a written breakdown of all commissions, fees, or uplifts. Ask them directly: How much are you being paid, and how is that reflected in the price I’ll pay? Transparency is now a legal requirement, and you have the right to ask.
2. Compare Quotes Without a Broker
Sometimes the simplest approach is to bypass intermediaries entirely. You can request quotes directly from suppliers, compare unit rates and standing charges, and assess contracts on their merits, without the added variable of a broker’s commission.
As noted by the regulator, businesses can “set up a business energy contract” themselves.
3. Use Trusted and Accredited Brokers Only
If you decide to use a broker, check that they’ll soon be registered under the new Ofgem regime. Post-regulation, they should meet fit-and-proper standards, follow a redress scheme, and be required to disclose fees.
4. Review Your Contract Before Signing , Especially Uplifts
Many brokers embed commissions by “uplifting” the unit rate. Even a small uplift per unit, multiplied over a long contract and high usage, can add thousands to your bills.
Check how the unit rate compares to current market averages and whether the uplift is justified. If it seems high, ask for a supplier-only quote without the broker’s addition, or a full explanation.
5. Stay Informed: Monitor Changes in Regulation
The regulatory overhaul is still rolling out. Stay updated on developments , when brokers become regulated, what disclosure requirements are active, and how supplier contracts are affected. This ensures your business remains protected in future renewals or negotiations.
Why This Matters for Small Businesses & Charities
For many small enterprises, energy bills are a substantial overhead , and every extra penny wasted on undisclosed fees is money that could go to wages, investment, or other core operations. Hidden commissions don’t only hurt your bottom line , they undermine trust in the energy market.
The “business energy broker dilemma” illustrates a systemic issue: when brokers operate without transparency, businesses lose not only money but agency. The recent regulatory reforms (under direction of the government and Ofgem) aim to shift the balance back, empowering businesses with clear, comparable information and fairer choices.
Especially for microbusinesses and charities , which often operate on tight margins , this transition couldn’t come at a more critical time
FAQs: The Business Energy Broker Dilemma, Avoid Hidden Commissions
What is the business energy broker dilemma?
The business energy broker dilemma refers to the issue where some brokers include hidden commissions within your business energy contract without clearly disclosing them. This means you might think you’re getting a good deal when, in reality, part of your energy cost includes undisclosed broker fees.
How do energy brokers make money?
Energy brokers usually earn money through commission. In some cases, this is clearly stated, but in others, the commission is added as an “uplift” on your unit rate. This practice creates the business energy broker dilemma, as businesses often don’t know how much of their total energy cost goes to the broker.
Are business energy brokers regulated in the UK?
Until recently, energy brokers weren’t directly regulated. However, the UK government and Ofgem have confirmed that brokers (also known as third-party intermediaries) will soon fall under Ofgem’s regulatory framework. Once active, brokers must register, disclose commissions, and follow new conduct rules.
Learn more about this on Ofgem.gov.uk.
How can I find out if my energy broker is charging hidden fees?
- How they’re paid
- Whether commission is included in your energy rate
- The total amount of commission for the contract duration
If they refuse to disclose this information, consider it a red flag and look for another provider.
What are hidden commissions in energy contracts?
Hidden commissions are payments made by suppliers to brokers without the customer’s knowledge. These are often added to the unit rate you’re quoted. Over time, they can cost your business thousands in unnecessary charges , one of the key issues behind the business energy broker dilemma.
Can I recover money from hidden broker commissions?
Yes, potentially. Businesses that were mis-sold energy contracts with undisclosed commissions may be able to claim compensation. Law firms across the UK are pursuing cases against brokers who failed to disclose their fees properly. Keep records of your energy bills and contracts to strengthen your claim.
What new protections is Ofgem introducing for businesses?
Ofgem is introducing mandatory commission transparency rules and requiring all brokers to register and follow a fit-and-proper test. This will ensure brokers are held accountable and must declare any commissions they receive , addressing the business energy broker dilemma directly.
Should I use a business energy broker at all?
You can , but choose carefully. A trustworthy broker can save you time and find competitive rates, but always verify how they’re compensated. Alternatively, you can compare business energy quotes directly from suppliers to eliminate the risk of hidden fees altogether.
How can small businesses protect themselves from broker scams?
- Ask for written commission disclosure
- Compare quotes directly from suppliers
- Check that your broker is registered with Ofgem (once regulation is active)
- Avoid contracts that feel rushed or pressured
What’s the best way to switch to a transparent business energy deal?
Start by reviewing your current contract for any commission terms. Then, compare quotes directly from suppliers or work with a transparent broker who commits to full disclosure. When in doubt, you can always consult the official Ofgem guide for businesses.
Final Thoughts: Make Energy Work for You, Not Against You
If you run or manage a small business, a charity, or any non-domestic enterprise, it’s time to take a close look at how you secure your energy. The “business energy broker dilemma” may sound technical , but in practice, it can cost you thousands without you realising it.
By demanding transparency, questioning uplifted quotes, and avoiding opaque intermediaries, you can reclaim control. The regulatory landscape is changing for the better , but only you can make sure your business is positioned to benefit.
Use your leverage; ask questions; demand clarity. Energy should power your business , not pad someone else’s pockets.
